Why should I provide my email address?

Start saving money today with our FREE daily newsletter packed with the best FREE and bargain Kindle book deals. We will never share your email address!
Sign Up Now!

How About a Kindle Controversy with Your Thanksgiving Turkey? Pirated Version of Salinger’s THE CATCHER IN THE RYE Shows Up at $1.35 on Kindle

by Steve Windwalker, BookGorilla.com

Here at BookGorilla we’re all about discovering and sharing incredible Kindle deals on bestselling books that our subscribers actually want to read, and this one would be at the top of the list on both counts … if only it were legit.

But early this morning — as we worked to serve up great Thanksgiving Day deals on books by John Grisham, J.K. Rowling, Lee Child, David Baldacci, Nicholas Sparks, George R.R. Martin and others — we happened upon an ebook version of J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, for sale in the Kindle store for just $1.35. We frankly didn’t care about the $1.35 price tag — it would be huge news at any price point.

Had there been some stunning tectonic shift in copyright claims overnight? Was it Jeff Bezos’ greatest get ever? Or just a study guide posing as the real thing?

None of the above, apparently. We downloaded the book and did a quick check in the initial pages as well as at several points further in to verify that the text offered is the text of the novel. Check.

But there were several very strong signals that this edition was not uploaded by a representative of the Salinger estate — the rather litigious Salinger estate, we might add — or anyone acting on the estate’s behalf:

  • The author’s name is spelled wrong on the Kindle page;
  • The “cover image” is the same kind of inelegant, unprofessional image that is often associated with public domain titles; and
  • The formatting throughout the text is inelegant and suggests that its production was generated by OCR scanning.

We know thousands will want to download this edition regardless of its provenance. But we would be remiss not to offer the caveat that it will not only be removed soon from the Kindle Store, but also — in all likelihood — from people’s Kindles, as well.

Happy Thanksgiving to all!

R.I.P. Jerome David Salinger

By Tom Dulaney

Kindle Nation Daily Contributing Editor

(Publisher’s Note: Please join me in welcoming Tom Dulaney to the contributors’ board here at Kindle Nation Daily. It’s a pleasure to have him aboard, and I hope you will enjoy his contributions as much as I do. –Stephen Windwalker)
Originally posted January 30, 2010 at Kindle Nation Daily – © Kindle Nation Daily 2010

J.D. Salinger  died on Wednesday, Jan. 27, leaving behind a reclusive reputation, a milestone novel of the mid-20th Century, a thin volume of nine short stories, two compilations that scream and shimmer with potential, and no presence whatsoever in epublishing.  His Author’s Page on Amazon displays the full canon of those of his works that were published in book form.

Sadly, none are available in the Kindle Store.  One hopes that Amazon is working as hard to get Little, Brown, Back Bay Books, and the Salinger Estate to rectify this gaping hole — and so much other great in-copyright writing from the past century — as it is to pressure MacMillan and other publishers to adhere to its intended price points for the Kindle catalogue.

For now, the closest we can come to digital-age reading of Salinger’s fiction is — if we happen to be subscribers in the traditional sense to The New Yorker — to read his stories as, with the truncated screen shot at the beginning of this post, they first appeared in the magazine in the two decades following World War II.

The Catcher in the Rye,  published in 1951, has long been a staple of college and, later, high school literature courses.  The scandalous teen angst of main character Holden Caulfield electrified generations of teen readers adrift in a world of grown ups who did not understand them.

Holden, burdened with the massive freight of early teen testosterone in a 1950s world of tease-and-denial, struggled to understand the rules of adulthood that suddenly confronted him.  The book, banned by the Catholic Legion of Decency and countless other guardians of American morality, enjoyed huge success and sales.  Millions of young men read Holden’s struggle while hidden beneath the covers,  flashlights illuminating the text, in the 1950s and early 1960s.

When those young men took over teaching duties as graduate assistants in college, Holden reared his confused adolescent head in lit classes and ascended to literary respectability.

Sad to say, as of Jan. 30, 2010, he hasn’t crossed the electronic border into the world of ebooks. Kindle Nation citizens should be aware that the Kindle titles with “Catcher in the Rye” in their titles that have been rocketing up the Kindle Store sales ranking ladder in the past few days are books about Salinger’s novel rather than the thing itself. The only downloadable works on Amazon relating to Catcher in the Rye are derivative works:  study guides, Cliffs Notes, and commentaries. For the moment, fresh copies of The Catcher in the Rye fetch prices of $5 to $7 as dead-tree books.  Cliffs Notes  on the novel run $5.99 on paper.

Plaintively, the little notice “Tell the Publisher!  I’d like to read this book on Kindle” sits forlornly on not only the original works but the study guides as well.

Death propels artists to fame and, for their estates, prosperity, as witnessed by the massive earnings last year of Elvis, John Lennon, George Harrison, and others beyond this veil of tears. If Catcher in the Rye fails to appear as an ebook in the next few days, it will be a mystery of cosmic proportions.

May Mr. Salinger rest in peace and the wisdom of his iconic novel arise again electronically.